BLM Sued for Rebuilding Fences on the Murphy Complex FireBOISE--The Western Watersheds Project is suing the Bureau of Land Management claiming the agency violated a 2005 settlement by authorizing fence reconstruction on 500,000 acres of federal land burned on last summer’s Murphy Complex Fire.
Rep. Bert Brackett, (R-Rogerson), ranches in the Three Creek area and is still recovering from the summer disaster. He told the Times News the lawsuit concerns him. "I find it amazing that they would do that, they had the chance to appeal the rehab plan last fall just like everybody else.”
According to U.S. District Court documents, the group wants the court to stop fence building in the Three Creek and surrounding areas south of Twin Falls. Western Watersheds also wants the court to stop grazing on 20 allotments covered in the 2005 court-stipulated settlement and another 36 allotments until an environmental impact statement is completed.
The group claims fencing and resuming the grazing allotments will disturb sage grouse and pygmy rabbit habitat. Both sides agree that the fire destoyed habitat but its too early to determine how much how much damage. The July fire scorched 650,000 acres of prime grazing land. Since then the BLM crews have done vigorous rehabilitation building 99 miles of burned fence and planting more than 1,600 shrubs at a cost of about $25 million. The agency has authorized additional grazing in unburned areas and an additional 400 miles of fence repair and that has angered the Watersheds group because of their historic opposition to grazing.
The lawsuit has not gone unnoticed at the Idaho Statehouse, lawmakers there are studying the effects of wildfire and grazing and looking at all the research they can find.
On March 6th Range Specialist Wally Butler told the Idaho House Agricultural Affairs Committee that conservation and range management goes hand in hand when done properly. Butler showed lawmakers photos taken of rangeland taken three weeks after the Murphy Complex fires. The photos showed rangeland just grazed and range un-grazed. The photos illustrated that grazed lands suffered significantly less damage because of less fuel load.
Steve Ritter shot these photos one month after the Murphy Complex Fire
Rehab crews also found less damage where fuel loads were the lightest. "One thing we had going for us is that a lot of this country was in excellent condition," Crane said. That’s helped rehabilitation and should speed up recovery.
Range expert Ron Kim with the Idaho Department of Agriculture testified about range recovery after a major fire. The BLM usually waits two years, but there’s evidence that a year recovery from wildfire is adequate prior to grazing. The year difference according to Kim can make or break a ranch recovering from fire.
The BLM has a number of experts currently studying the effects of grazing on wildfire and Rehabilitation that started in August continues this spring.
"We got a tremendous amount done," Ken Crane, rangeland management specialist with the Twin Falls BLM district. The Agency is also following the best science in wild land fire management and they want to amend its fire prevention program that affects southern Idaho. That includes changing 12 land use plans written between 1975 and 1988, and calls for reducing cheat grass, brush and fuel-loads the agency says is responsible for huge blow ups like the Murphy Complex fire.
"We took what we thought was damaged the most and tried to reseed that," Ken Crane of the BLM said. "We know we didn't get it all."
A BLM spokesman says it’s latest plan would increase fuel load treatment on the Idaho range from more than 25,000 acres to 154,000 acres each year for the next decade.