
Map courtesy of the Bureau of Land Management
Ranchers Wage War of Words on Facebook
Boise--When the El Paso Corporation announced their shocking, precedent-setting, $20 million deal with two environmental groups to ‘not oppose’ the company’s planned Ruby Pipeline that runs through Wyoming to Oregon it raised some eyebrows. Western ranchers were shocked at first, now they’re fighting back on Facebook.
Tina Harrington of Lander, Wyoming posted her disappointment on El Paso’s Facebook page: “So sorry to see that you are involved with Western Watersheds. They have their own niche agenda, and it does not fit with what is practical and ethical. This alliance will make you VERY unpopular! Ranching is the heart of this country, and WWP would like to cut it out.”
El Paso will pay Jon Marvel’s Western Watersheds Project and the Oregon Natural Desert Association for not opposing the pipeline. They will be paid a mountain of cash for not filing lawsuits opposing the pipeline that will cut across prime range and wildlife habitat.
The week-old announcement is still playing out on Facebook and gaining momentum, with ranchers across three-state area outraged and perplexed by the multi-million dollar buyout and the reasoning behind it.
“It’s something we didn’t have to do. We chose to do it,” El Paso spokesman Richard Wheatley told the Elko Dailey Free Press on Friday. “The bottom line is we think it’s a preferable approach than being involved in litigation.” El Paso thinks the $20 million dollar deal is ‘in line with the company’s outreach efforts to be good stewards of the land,’ Wheatley said.
Wyoming, Idaho and Oregon Ranchers are outraged that the astronomical amount of cash will fill environmental group coffers with no oversight and worse yet will fund groups hell-bent on their destruction. The ranchers point out that the Watershed project has done very little habitat improvement on the range and say almost all the money will pay for lawyers that will in turn kick them off the land.
Rancher Jon Griggs of Elko, Nevada wrote on El Paso's Facebook Wall: “I admire your environmental efforts on Western lands but these groups you're funding will spend your money on litigation rather than conservation (unless you're really just buying them off, that I can totally understand).”
Rancher Troy Hadrick of Falkton, South Dakota posted a plea to the Natural Gas Company asking them to explain their reasoning for the buy out.
“I’m looking forward to a call back from your Community Relations department,” posted Hadrick. “About why you have chosen to give $20 million to environmental groups that are trying to put ranching families out of business.” The El Paso Corporation, besieged by posts, promised to call the rancher back.
Western Watershed’s Jon Marvel told the Elko Dailey Free Press that they would not delay or litigate Ruby Pipeline, he told the Press that El Paso is setting up a $15 million conservation fund for Western Watersheds and $5-million for the Oregon environmental group. He said they’ll use the cash to buy grazing permits from ranchers. He added that they will ask Congress to permanently retire grazing permits in these cases.
“It’s unprecedented to have the support of industry to work for the retirement of public grazing permits,” Marvel he told the Press, emphasizing that the fund would only buy permits from “willing sellers.”
On Western Watershed’s Facebook site there’s no mention of the buy out from El Paso Corporation. Ranch insiders say that's curious for a group that boasts their victories in court yet deftly spins major setbacks.
Marlina Jones from Owyhee county posted on the El Paso site asking questions, “why would you buy off Western Watershed? Just to save some time and litigation? I don't understand. Are you aware of the damage this group does to the American Rancher/Farmer, I suggest you do a little research on this group. I do not mean go to their website and read their propaganda, but the real stories of hard working people that they have ruined.”
Facebook users asked over and over again for El Paso to explain and examine their decision closely. They’re worried that the money that bought the group’s silence will in turn fund their destruction forever ending the legacy that not only settled the west, but feeds the country.